Share Prices & Company Research

Market News

16 Nov 2026 | 13:50

The Time of Maximum Pessimism Is the Best Time to Buy: Sir John Templeton on Buying Stocks in a Crash

(Sharecast News) - The Investor's Playbook: 20 Investment Philosophies That Could Change How You Think About the Stock Market "Bull markets are born on pessimism, grow on scepticism, mature on optimism and die on euphoria." - Sir John Templeton

When stock markets are plunging, the headlines are frightening, investors are selling and even experienced fund managers are questioning their assumptions, buying shares can feel like the last thing anyone should do. But legendary investor Sir John Templeton believed that these moments of extreme pessimism could offer some of the greatest opportunities in the stock market. His philosophy was summed up in one of investing's most famous observations: "The time of maximum pessimism is the best time to buy."

Templeton's approach was rooted in a simple but powerful idea. When fear dominates the market, investors can become so focused on the immediate dangers that they overlook the longer-term value of the businesses they are selling. A recession, financial crisis or market crash can send shares tumbling far below what a company might be worth under more normal conditions. For investors with the patience, research and financial resources to look beyond the panic, that disconnect can create opportunities. However, buying during a crash is not simply a matter of purchasing whatever has fallen the furthest. Templeton's real skill was identifying businesses and markets where pessimism had become excessive relative to their underlying prospects. His philosophy offers a valuable lesson for investors navigating today's stock market: sometimes the best opportunities appear when confidence is at its lowest.

Who was Sir John Templeton?

Sir John Templeton was an American-born British investor, fund manager and philanthropist, widely regarded as one of the most successful global stock pickers of the 20th century. Born in Tennessee in 1912, Templeton graduated from Yale University in 1934 before becoming a Rhodes Scholar at Oxford University, where he studied law at Balliol College. He began his Wall Street career in 1938, but it was the outbreak of the Second World War that provided the foundation for one of his most famous investment decisions.

In 1939, as war broke out in Europe and uncertainty gripped financial markets, Templeton instructed his broker to buy shares in 104 companies trading at $1 or less each. He borrowed money to finance the purchases, investing in some businesses that were already facing bankruptcy. Only four of the 104 companies ultimately proved worthless. The investment demonstrated his willingness to look beyond the prevailing mood of the market and identify potential value where others saw only danger.

Templeton went on to establish the Templeton Growth Fund in 1954, developing an international investment approach at a time when many American investors concentrated almost exclusively on their domestic market. He became known for searching across countries, industries and markets for undervalued opportunities, particularly where investors had become excessively pessimistic. In 1987, he was knighted for his services to philanthropy. He died in 2008, aged 95, leaving behind an investment philosophy that continues to influence value investors and contrarians around the world.

What does 'maximum pessimism' mean?

Templeton's philosophy is based on the relationship between investor sentiment and share prices. During a bull market, confidence tends to build. Investors become increasingly optimistic about economic growth, corporate profits and future returns. More people want to own shares, valuations rise and previously overlooked risks can be ignored. Eventually, optimism can become excessive. Investors may pay increasingly high prices for businesses because they assume good conditions will continue indefinitely. The reverse happens during a bear market.

Economic forecasts deteriorate, companies issue profit warnings, unemployment rises and investors begin to question whether businesses can survive. As fear spreads, shareholders rush to sell, often without considering whether the long-term prospects of the companies they own have fundamentally changed. This can create a disconnect between a company's share price and its underlying value. Templeton believed that the most attractive buying opportunities often emerge when pessimism is widespread and investors have already priced in an extremely negative outlook.

His philosophy does not suggest that every falling share is a bargain. Rather, it encourages investors to investigate whether the market's expectations have become too pessimistic. A company whose shares have fallen 50% may still be expensive if its future profits are likely to collapse. Another whose shares have fallen 30% may represent an attractive opportunity if its business remains fundamentally sound. The important distinction is between a falling share price and a genuine undervaluation.

Why buying during a stock market crash can work

There are several reasons why periods of extreme pessimism can create opportunities for long-term investors.

1. Investors can become excessively emotional

Financial markets are driven by both fundamentals and psychology. During a crash, fear can overwhelm rational analysis, encouraging investors to sell simply because everyone else appears to be doing so. This can create opportunities for investors who remain calm and assess businesses on their long-term prospects.

2. Valuations can become more attractive

When share prices fall sharply, the price investors pay for a company's earnings, assets or future cash flows may become more reasonable. A business that looked expensive during a bull market could become attractively valued after a major correction, provided its underlying financial position remains sound.

3. Expectations can become too negative

Share prices reflect expectations about the future, not simply a company's current performance. If investors expect a prolonged recession, falling profits or a collapse in demand, a company may be priced for a much worse outcome than ultimately materialises. If the business proves more resilient than expected, its share price can recover even if the wider economic environment remains challenging.

4. Long-term investors have time on their side

Investors buying during a crash rarely know exactly when markets will recover. However, those with a sufficiently long investment horizon may be able to benefit as economic conditions improve and investor confidence returns. Templeton's approach was not about predicting the exact bottom of the market. It was about recognising when prices offered an attractive potential return relative to the risks.

Practical UK example: Rolls-Royce and the Covid market crash

Rolls Royce provides a striking example of the opportunities and dangers associated with buying during a market crisis. The FTSE 100 engineering group was hit particularly hard by the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020. Its civil aerospace business depends heavily on aircraft flying hours, with airlines paying for engine maintenance and servicing as aircraft are used. When international travel collapsed and aircraft were grounded around the world, the company's revenues and cash flow came under enormous pressure. Investors feared that the disruption could last for years. Rolls-Royce's shares fell dramatically, eventually reaching levels not seen for many years. The company was facing a genuinely serious financial challenge. Its 2020 full-year results showed a free cash outflow of £4.2bn, while it raised substantial new debt and equity to strengthen its balance sheet.

For a Templeton-style investor, the question was whether the pandemic had permanently undermined the company's long-term prospects or whether it had created a temporary crisis for a business with valuable engineering expertise, established customer relationships and a significant position in the global aerospace industry. Those who believed international air travel would eventually recover could see potential value in the depressed share price. But the risks were considerable. The company needed to raise capital, restructure its operations and survive an uncertain period in which its largest commercial market had almost disappeared. The subsequent recovery in aviation, improvements in the company's operations and stronger financial performance helped drive a substantial share-price recovery over the following years.

Rolls-Royce demonstrates the potential rewards of buying when pessimism is extreme, but also why investors must examine a company's balance sheet and ability to survive before assuming that a falling share price represents an opportunity.

Practical international example: Meta and the technology sell-off

The US technology group Meta owner of Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, offers another example of how extreme pessimism can create investment opportunities. In 2022, Meta experienced a sharp deterioration in investor sentiment. Rising interest rates, weaker digital advertising conditions, increased competition from TikTok and concerns about the scale of its spending on the metaverse all contributed to a dramatic fall in its share price. The market began questioning whether the company could sustain its previous growth and whether its heavy investment in virtual reality and the metaverse would ever generate adequate returns.

For investors applying Templeton's philosophy, the key question was whether Meta's underlying advertising business had been permanently damaged or whether the market had become excessively pessimistic about its future. The company still owned some of the world's largest social media platforms, with enormous audiences and an established advertising infrastructure.

In 2023, Meta reported revenue of $134.9bn, up 16% from the previous year, while operating income increased by 62%. The improvement reflected stronger advertising revenue and demonstrated that the underlying business retained considerable earning power. The subsequent recovery in investor confidence and share price illustrated how quickly market sentiment can change when a company's performance proves stronger than feared. However, the example also highlights an important point: investors needed to distinguish between Meta's established advertising business and the risks associated with its longer-term investment commitments. A recovery in one part of the business did not remove the uncertainty surrounding every part of the investment case.

Buying a crash is not the same as buying every falling share

One of the biggest mistakes investors can make when applying Templeton's philosophy is assuming that the shares suffering the largest falls offer the greatest opportunities. Some companies are cheap because investors have overreacted to temporary problems. Others are cheap because their businesses are deteriorating, their competitive advantages are disappearing or their balance sheets are becoming unsustainable. This distinction is particularly important during a recession or financial crisis. A business with high levels of debt may struggle to survive a prolonged downturn. A retailer facing structural changes in consumer behaviour may never return to its previous level of profitability. A technology company whose products have become obsolete may be unable to recover, regardless of how far its shares have fallen.

Templeton's 1939 investment in 104 companies is instructive here. He did not put all his money into one apparently cheap business. He spread his investment across a large number of companies, accepting that some would fail while others could generate substantial returns. For private investors, the lesson is to look for a combination of attractive valuation, financial resilience and a credible route to recovery.

How to identify opportunities during a market crash

Templeton's approach can be turned into a practical framework for investors looking to identify undervalued shares during periods of market turmoil.

1. Look for businesses with strong underlying fundamentals

Start with companies that have established products, competitive advantages, recurring revenues or a strong market position. A temporary economic shock may reduce profits, but a business with loyal customers and a sustainable competitive advantage could recover when conditions improve.

2. Examine the balance sheet

A company can survive a difficult trading environment only if it has sufficient financial resources. Look at net debt, cash reserves, interest payments, debt maturities and access to additional funding. Highly leveraged companies may be particularly vulnerable if a recession lasts longer than expected.

3. Compare the share price with long-term earning potential

A falling share price is only useful if it creates a valuation that offers an attractive potential return. Consider the company's historical profitability, expected cash flows, asset value and ability to generate sustainable earnings over the next five to ten years.

4. Separate temporary problems from structural decline

A company suffering from a short-term drop in demand may recover when economic conditions improve. However, a business losing market share because of technological change, new competitors or changing consumer habits may face a much more difficult challenge. Investors need to understand why the share price has fallen before deciding whether the market has overreacted.

5. Avoid trying to predict the exact market bottom

Even experienced investors struggle to identify the precise moment when a bear market has ended. Share prices can fall further after an initial recovery, and apparently attractive valuations can become even cheaper. Rather than investing everything at once, some investors choose to build positions gradually, spreading purchases over several months. This can reduce the risk of committing all their capital immediately before another market decline, although it does not guarantee a profit.

The importance of global investing

One of Templeton's most important contributions was his belief that investors should look beyond their domestic stock market. He recognised that attractive opportunities could emerge in different countries at different times. A market that had performed poorly for years could offer better value than one where investors had become excessively optimistic. This remains relevant today.

Investors concentrating exclusively on UK equities may miss opportunities in the US, Europe and Asia. Equally, investors focused on fashionable US technology shares could overlook attractively valued businesses elsewhere. Templeton's approach encourages investors to compare valuations across markets and industries rather than assuming that the best opportunities will always be found close to home. It also provides a reminder of the benefits of diversification. Different economies, currencies, sectors and political environments can respond differently to the same global shock.

However, international investing introduces additional risks, including currency movements, political instability, differences in accounting standards and local regulatory uncertainty. Global diversification should therefore be based on research rather than simply buying shares in unfamiliar markets because they appear cheap.

The limitations and risks of buying during a crash

Templeton's philosophy is compelling, but it is not a guarantee of success. Buying during a market crash requires patience, financial discipline and a willingness to accept that the investment may initially move further against you. There are several important limitations.

The market may be right to be pessimistic. Investors sometimes sell shares because a company's long-term prospects have genuinely deteriorated. A falling share price can reflect permanent damage rather than temporary fear.

The bottom is impossible to predict consistently. A market can continue falling for months after valuations begin to look attractive. Investors who commit all their capital too early may find themselves unable to take advantage of even better opportunities later.

Cheap shares can become cheaper. A low price-to-earnings ratio or a large discount to historical valuations does not automatically make a stock a bargain. Earnings estimates may still be too optimistic, particularly during a recession.

Liquidity matters. Investors who buy during a crash need to be confident that they will not require the money in the short term. Being forced to sell during a further downturn can turn a temporary paper loss into a permanent one.

Not every recovery is equal. Some companies recover strongly after a crisis, while others never regain their previous market position. Investors should not assume that a share price will eventually return to its previous high simply because it has fallen dramatically.

Emotions can work against investors. Buying when headlines are frightening requires considerable conviction. It is often easier to say that a crash represents an opportunity than to commit money when markets are falling and economic uncertainty is rising. Templeton's approach is therefore best understood as a framework for identifying potential value, not a simple market-timing strategy.

Five lessons from Sir John Templeton for private investors

His philosophy can be distilled into five practical lessons:

Do not follow the crowd blindly. When everyone is optimistic, valuations may already reflect unrealistic expectations. When everyone is pessimistic, there may be opportunities worth investigating.

Focus on value, not just price. A share that has fallen 70% is not necessarily cheap. Consider what the underlying business could realistically be worth.

Look beyond the immediate crisis. Consider whether the company can recover over the next five to ten years, rather than focusing exclusively on the next trading update.

Diversify your investments. Even thorough research cannot guarantee that every distressed company will survive. Spreading risk across businesses and markets can help limit the impact of individual failures.

Be patient and disciplined. Market recoveries can take time, and investors should be prepared for further volatility after buying.

The final lesson: opportunity often arrives when confidence disappears

Sir John Templeton's investment philosophy challenges one of the most deeply ingrained instincts in the stock market: the desire to buy when prices are rising and sell when they are falling. He believed that investors who followed the crowd would struggle to achieve superior returns because they would repeatedly buy when optimism was already reflected in valuations and sell when fear had driven prices down.

His most famous lesson remains as relevant today as it was in 1939. The greatest investment opportunities can emerge when pessimism is widespread, confidence has collapsed and investors are unwilling to look beyond the immediate crisis. But successful contrarian investing requires more than courage. It demands careful research, a realistic assessment of a company's financial strength, an understanding of valuation and the patience to wait for the market to recognise what the investor believes it has overlooked. The aim is not to buy every share that crashes. It is to identify quality businesses whose long-term prospects remain intact, even when the market has temporarily lost faith in them.

As Templeton understood, the best time to buy is often when doing so feels most uncomfortable. The challenge is knowing when pessimism has created an opportunity - and when it is warning of something much worse.

Get in touch today
Join Redmayne Bentley
Talk to us now about opening a new portfolio or transferring your portfolio from another provider
0113 243 6941
Get in touch today
Contact your local office
Contact your local office to find out more
The value of your investments and the income from them may go down as well as up, and you could get back less than you invested.