16 Nov 2026 | 13:46
It's Not About Being Right, It's About Being Less Wrong: Howard Marks on Investment Risk
(Sharecast News) - The Investor's Playbook: 20 Investment Philosophies That Could Change How You Think About the Stock Market
"Risk means more things can happen than will happen." - Howard Marks
Successful investing is often presented as a search for certainty. Find the next big winner, identify the company with the strongest growth prospects, predict where interest rates are heading and buy before everyone else catches on. But what if the key to investment success is not about getting every prediction right? What if it is about making fewer costly mistakes, recognising what you do not know and ensuring that the risks you take are worth the potential reward? That is the thinking behind one of the most important lessons associated with veteran investor Howard Marks: it's not about being right all the time; it's about being less wrong than everyone else.
Marks has spent decades arguing that investors should pay as much attention to the possibility of losing money as they do to the prospect of making it. His approach challenges the instinct to chase returns at any cost, replacing it with a more disciplined focus on risk, valuation, market psychology and the limits of human knowledge. In a market increasingly influenced by artificial intelligence, geopolitical uncertainty, shifting interest rates and changing investor sentiment, that philosophy may be more relevant than ever.
Who is Howard Marks?
Howard Marks is the co-founder and co-chairman of Oaktree Capital Management, one of the world's leading investment firms specialising in credit and alternative investments. He began his investment career in 1969, initially working as an equity research analyst before moving into senior investment roles at Citicorp and TCW Group. At TCW, he led teams focused on distressed debt, high-yield bonds and convertible securities. In 1995, Marks co-founded Oaktree, building a business around a philosophy that placed risk control at the centre of investment decisions.
He became widely respected for his investment memos, which explore market cycles, investor psychology, valuation and the dangers of excessive confidence. His books, including The Most Important Thing: Uncommon Sense for the Thoughtful Investor and Mastering the Market Cycle, have become influential reading for professional and private investors alike.
Marks' central argument is deceptively simple: investment success is not just about identifying attractive opportunities. It is also about avoiding situations in which the potential losses are disproportionate to the likely gains. Oaktree's stated philosophy reflects this approach. The firm seeks superior investment performance with less-than-commensurate risk, arguing that avoiding significant losers can be just as important as finding exceptional winners.
What does 'being less wrong' actually mean?
The phrase captures a broader investment philosophy rather than a promise that investors can avoid mistakes. Marks recognises that nobody can predict the future with complete accuracy. Economic forecasts can be wrong, corporate earnings can disappoint and unexpected events can change the outlook for an entire industry. Even a carefully researched investment can lose money.
The difference between a successful and unsuccessful investor, therefore, is not necessarily the ability to make perfect predictions. It is the ability to assess the range of possible outcomes, understand what could go wrong and avoid taking risks that are not adequately rewarded.
Consider two investors looking at the same company. The first sees a business with strong sales growth, an exciting product and a rapidly expanding market. They buy the shares because they believe earnings will rise. The second reaches the same conclusion about the company's prospects but asks a different question: how much optimism is already reflected in the share price? If the shares are already valued on the assumption that the company will deliver exceptional growth for years, even a good set of results may not be enough to drive the price higher. Any disappointment could trigger a substantial correction. Both investors may be right about the underlying business. But the second has considered the relationship between expectations, valuation and risk. That is the essence of Marks' approach. It is not enough to identify a good company. Investors must also consider whether the price offers an attractive return for the risks involved.
The importance of second-level thinking
One of Marks' best-known concepts is second-level thinking, which he developed in The Most Important Thing. First-level thinking is straightforward. It involves forming an opinion about a company or the wider economy and acting accordingly.
For example:
A company is growing quickly, so its shares should rise.
Interest rates are falling, so equities should perform well.
A business is facing difficulties, so its shares should be avoided.
A technology is transforming an industry, so companies involved in it must be attractive investments.
Second-level thinking goes further. It asks what other investors already believe, how much of that belief is reflected in the share price and what might happen if expectations prove too optimistic or pessimistic. A second-level investor might look at a fast-growing company and conclude that its prospects are excellent, but that the market has already priced in even better performance. Equally, they might examine a struggling business and decide that its problems are serious but that the market has already discounted an even worse outcome.
The key question becomes not simply whether an investment is good or bad, but whether it is better or worse than the market expects. This distinction is crucial because share prices respond not only to business performance but also to changes in expectations. A company can report rising profits and still see its shares fall if investors had anticipated stronger growth. Another can announce disappointing results but rise if the figures are less damaging than feared. Being right about the direction of a company's performance is therefore not always enough. Investors need to understand what the market has already priced in.
Why risk matters more than most investors realise
Marks has repeatedly warned that investors tend to misunderstand risk. When markets are rising, confidence increases. Investors become more comfortable with borrowing, valuations expand and previously cautious assumptions are replaced by optimistic forecasts. At precisely the point when prices are becoming more expensive, risk can appear to be falling.The opposite can happen during market downturns. Falling share prices, negative headlines and widespread pessimism can make investors believe that risk is increasing everywhere. But Marks argues that the relationship between risk and price is more complicated. An unpopular company may become less risky as its share price falls, provided its underlying business remains viable. Conversely, a fashionable company can become increasingly risky if its valuation rises to levels that leave little room for disappointment.
In his 2015 memo It's Not Easy, Marks explored the idea that investment risk can be greatest when it is least perceived. When everyone believes an asset is safe, investors may be willing to pay too much for it. When everyone believes an asset is dangerous, pessimism may already be reflected in its price. This does not mean that every unpopular share is a bargain or that every highly valued company is destined to fall. It means investors should distinguish between the quality of a business and the price they are being asked to pay for it. A wonderful company can be a poor investment at the wrong valuation. A troubled company can offer an attractive opportunity if its problems are manageable and the share price reflects excessive pessimism.
How Howard Marks' philosophy applies to today's stock market
The modern stock market provides plenty of examples of why investors need to think beyond the obvious. Artificial intelligence has created enormous opportunities for companies supplying the technology, infrastructure and computing power behind the revolution. But identifying a transformative technology is not the same as identifying the best investment. Investors must consider how much future growth is already reflected in valuations, how much capital companies will need to spend and which businesses will ultimately capture the profits.
In November 2026, Marks highlighted the difficulty of predicting the eventual winners, profitability and investment returns from AI. His central concern was not whether the technology could be transformative, but whether investors could reliably identify where the economic benefits would accrue and whether current spending and valuations were justified. That is a classic example of second-level thinking: separating enthusiasm about a technology from the question of whether a particular share represents good value. The same discipline applies to interest rates, energy markets, defence spending and the wider economic outlook.
Investors do not need to know exactly what will happen next. They need to understand how their investments might behave under different scenarios and whether they can withstand an outcome that is less favourable than expected.
Practical example: Rolls-Royce and the importance of expectations
Rolls Royce provides a useful UK example of how investors can apply Marks' thinking. The FTSE 100 engineering group operates across civil aerospace, defence and power systems. Its fortunes are influenced by factors including aircraft engine utilisation, airline activity, defence demand, operational performance and the long-term development of its power technologies. A first-level investor might look at improving demand for air travel and conclude that Rolls-Royce should benefit. A second-level investor would ask more searching questions. How much of the recovery in civil aerospace is already reflected in the share price? Are expectations for future margins realistic? Can the company deliver its operational targets? What happens if airline activity weakens or costs rise? How much of the investment case depends on technologies that may take years to become commercially significant? These questions do not necessarily lead to a negative view of the company. They help investors understand what needs to go right for the investment to succeed.
If expectations are already extremely high, even a strong business performance may not translate into strong share-price returns. If the market is underestimating the company's ability to deliver, the potential reward may be more attractive. The lesson is to assess the investment case rather than simply the corporate story.
Practical example: BP and the risks of forecasting
BP illustrates another aspect of Marks' philosophy: the danger of relying too heavily on macroeconomic predictions. Oil and gas companies are exposed to a wide range of external influences, including crude prices, geopolitical developments, production decisions, regulation, currency movements and the cost of financing. An investor might buy BP shares because they expect oil prices to rise. Another might avoid the stock because they believe the energy transition will reduce demand for fossil fuels. Both views may be reasonable, but neither is certain.
A Marks-inspired approach would look beyond a single forecast. It would consider how the business might perform across a range of oil-price environments, the strength of its balance sheet, its capital expenditure commitments, its dividend sustainability and the valuation being paid for the shares. The investor should also consider what the market already expects. If the share price assumes persistently high oil prices, a modest decline could create pressure. If the market is excessively pessimistic, the shares may offer better value than the headlines suggest. This is not an argument for ignoring the oil-price outlook. It is an argument for avoiding an investment decision that depends on getting one difficult prediction exactly right.
International example: NVIDIA and the AI investment debate
NVIDIA is one of the clearest international examples of the distinction between identifying a successful business and assessing the risks of owning its shares. The US semiconductor company has become central to the development of artificial intelligence, supplying the advanced processors and computing platforms used by data centres and technology companies. Its growth has been extraordinary. In its fiscal 2026 results, NVIDIA reported revenue of $215.9bn, an increase of 65% year on year, alongside substantial growth in operating income and earnings. But Marks' philosophy encourages investors to look beyond impressive headline numbers. What level of future growth is already built into the valuation? How sustainable is demand for AI infrastructure? Will customers continue to spend at the same rate? Could competition, changing technology or the economics of AI services alter the industry's profitability?
Even if NVIDIA remains a major beneficiary of AI, investors could still lose money if they pay too much for its shares or if future growth falls short of market expectations. Equally, a temporary slowdown in growth would not automatically mean the long-term investment case had collapsed. The important task is to distinguish between the quality of the company, the durability of its competitive position and the price at which its shares are being bought.
Five questions investors should ask before buying a share
Marks' approach can be translated into a practical checklist for private investors.
1. What could go wrong?
Investors should identify the main threats to the business, rather than concentrating exclusively on its potential. These might include rising debt, weaker demand, increased competition, regulatory changes, operational problems or exposure to a particular economic cycle.
2. How much optimism is already priced in?
A company can be performing well while its shares are becoming increasingly vulnerable. Consider whether the valuation assumes unusually strong earnings growth, expanding profit margins or a favourable economic environment.
3. What happens if the investment thesis is wrong?
Think about the potential downside, not just the expected return. Could a disappointing trading update cause a modest correction, or could it undermine the entire investment case? Is the balance sheet strong enough to withstand a difficult period?
4. Am I being compensated for the risk?
Higher potential returns should come with an appropriate assessment of the risks involved. A speculative company with uncertain earnings may offer substantial upside, but investors should not assume that a low share price automatically makes it attractive.
5. What does the market believe that I might be missing?
It is tempting to assume that other investors have overlooked an obvious opportunity. But markets are competitive, and the consensus may contain valuable information. A strong investment case needs more than a different opinion. It needs a reason why that opinion is likely to be better.
The limitations of the Howard Marks approach
There is a danger in taking risk control too far. Investors who become excessively concerned about potential losses may avoid opportunities altogether. Markets rarely offer complete certainty, and waiting for a supposedly risk-free entry point can mean missing years of investment returns. Marks himself recognises this tension. Active investors cannot seek to outperform without accepting the possibility of underperforming. Taking a position that differs from the consensus can produce superior returns, but it can also result in significant mistakes. There are several other limitations worth considering.
Risk cannot be eliminated. Even a diversified portfolio of profitable, established companies can suffer during a severe market downturn. Unexpected events can affect businesses in ways that investors could not reasonably have anticipated.
Valuation is not an exact science. Investors can disagree about the future cash flows, growth prospects and appropriate valuation of a company. A share that looks cheap on one set of assumptions may prove expensive on another.
Being different does not automatically mean being right. Contrarian investors can mistake a genuinely deteriorating business for an undervalued opportunity. A falling share price is not, by itself, evidence of a bargain.
Defensive investing can become overly cautious. Investors who focus too heavily on avoiding losses may hold too much cash, miss opportunities or sell strong businesses during temporary periods of uncertainty.
Short-term results can be misleading. A sensible investment decision can produce a poor outcome because of unpredictable events. Equally, a reckless decision can make money by chance. Investors should judge the quality of their process over time, not simply by the outcome of one trade.
The objective is not to avoid every mistake. It is to avoid allowing individual mistakes to cause disproportionate damage.
Why avoiding big losses can be the key to long-term returns
One of the strongest arguments for Marks' philosophy is the mathematics of investment losses. The larger the fall in a portfolio, the greater the return required to recover. For example, an investment that falls by 20% needs to rise by 25% to return to its original value. A 50% loss requires a 100% gain just to break even.
Portfolio loss
Gain required to recover
10%
11.1%
20%
25%
30%
42.9%
40%
66.7%
50%
100%
60%
150%
This asymmetry explains why protecting capital can be so important. An investor who avoids a catastrophic loss does not necessarily need to find the next multibagger to achieve attractive long-term returns. By preserving capital, they retain the ability to participate in future opportunities and benefit from compounding.
That does not mean investors should sell every share that falls or avoid all volatile businesses. Volatility and permanent loss are not the same thing. But understanding the difference is central to assessing whether a risk is worth taking.
The final lesson: humility is an investment advantage
Howard Marks' philosophy is ultimately a lesson in intellectual humility. Investors are surrounded by information, forecasts and confident opinions. Financial markets reward conviction when it is justified, but they can punish overconfidence when reality turns out differently.
The best investors recognise that the future is uncertain. They do not assume that a good company is automatically a good investment, that a popular share is safe or that a falling share price must represent an opportunity. Instead, they examine the relationship between price, value, expectations and risk. They consider what could go wrong, prepare for outcomes they cannot predict and avoid taking risks that could permanently impair their capital.
For private investors, the practical message is clear: do not make being right the only measure of investment success. Try to understand what the market expects, question your own assumptions and make sure that the potential reward justifies the risks involved. You will still make mistakes. Every investor does. But if you can avoid the biggest ones, you may discover that you do not need to be right nearly as often as you think.